Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Georgia McGraw's avatar

Brilliant essay!

"People are not homeless, they are unhoused: someone unhoused them. Folk are not illegal immigrants, they are undocumented: someone failed to provide them with documents. People are not of a marginal or minority group, they are marginalised or minoritised: someone marginalised or minoritised them."

Well of course, the New Devil (capitalism, patriarchy, etc) did it to the poor wee lambs...

Expand full comment
Robert Paterson's avatar

Brilliant love this coda

Systematically selecting against merit, as the US has been doing for decades, does not help. But that is also a manifestation of decision-makers insulated from the consequences of their decisions.

Progressive politics is based on an imagined future from which there is no information, its moral and political benchmark has no reality test. Progressives also gravitate to occupations and sectors (public service, non-profits) with weak reality-tests, just as conservatives gravitate to occupations with strong reality-tests (farming, mining, etc). Network effects then intensify these patterns.

The weaker the reality-tests, the less the cost of error, the higher the efficient rate of self-deception.

Progressives have a long tradition of producing toxic bullshit—pushed for persuasive effect without regard to its truth. Lenin, Stalin, Mao, Castro, Chavez are great men doing great things, for example. The hormonal and surgical mutilation and sterilisation of minors is cutting-edge kindness. Defunding the police will make us safer.

The more a society has social niches insulated from reality tests, the more it becomes dominated by progressive politics and the higher the level of toxic bullshit in its public discourse.

The welfare state—including its warfare arm—does not select for victory or solutions, it selects for activity. This provides the basis for self-reinforcing feedbacks of social dysfunction, where entrenching, or expanding, social pathologies expands the resource base of the welfare state, provides rhetorical support for activism and expands opportunities to colonise the apparatus (government, non-profit, corporate) of the welfare state.

Expand full comment
52 more comments...

No posts