Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Helen Dale's avatar

Apologies Lorenzo and I haven't been around as much as usual, we're both preoccupied with Christmas stuff at the moment. As usual, loads of good comments, but also a bit of obsession & hobby-horsing. Please keep it civil.

Expand full comment
Richard Fulmer's avatar

We will not win the battle against wokery through logic and reason because the woke reject logic and reason. Nor will we win by becoming Trumpian caricatures of what they claim we are. It may be that in this case, as in many others, laughter is the best medicine. What logic cannot refute, ridicule can. And the task of ridiculing the woke is made infinitely easier because the woke routinely make themselves ridiculous.

For example, here is a sample of what passes for woke “thought”:

• The absolute truth is that there are no absolute truths.

• No culture is better than another. Western Civilization is bad.

• Gender is a social construct; there are no differences between the sexes. All men are bad.

• Race is a social construct; there are no differences between the races. All white people are bad.

• Stereotyping people is wrong. All white people are racist oppressors.

• White people are racist by virtue of their skin color and can never be not racist. At best, they can only endlessly atone for their whiteness and racism.

• Minorities cannot improve their lives or those of their loved ones until white people stop being racist. White people can never be not racist.

• We will continue to attack white people for being racist until they stop being racist. White people can never be not racist.

• White silence is violence. White speech is violence.

• Believing that all Muslims are guilty of terrorism is bad. Believing that all white people are guilty of slavery is good.

• Segregation is bad. Separate black college dorms and black graduation ceremonies are good.

• “White flight” from inner cities is racist. White migration to inner cities (aka “gentrification”) is racist.

• The “bourgeois virtues” of self-reliance, persistence, reliability, thrift, diligence, honesty, creativity, tolerance, and civility are white traits, and promoting them is racist. The fact that people who reject those traits are more likely to be poor is proof that America is systemically racist.

• Diversity strengthens us by exposure to different viewpoints. Adopting diverse viewpoints is “cultural appropriation.”

• Race is a social construct that has no biological basis. Pharmaceutical companies are racist because they don’t include enough biologically diverse minority subjects in their drug trials.

• Diversity of skin color is good. Diversity of thought is bad.

• Religion leads to conflict and war. Islam is the religion of peace.

• The Left’s violence is free speech. The Right’s free speech is violence.

• Sending police officers to minority areas is racist. Pulling police protection out of minority areas is racist.

• Only racists believe FBI statistics indicating that some minorities disproportionately commit crimes. Enforcing criminal law is racist because laws disproportionately impact minorities who commit more crimes.

• We need more gun laws. Gun laws are racist, so we must stop enforcing the ones we already have.

• We will continue releasing thieves, rapists, and murderers onto the streets until crime is eliminated.

• Noting cultural and racial differences is racist. Not acknowledging the different strengths and contributions of other cultures and races is racist.

• Your thoughts and beliefs are nothing but excuses for dismissing the beliefs of others and subjugating them. We therefore dismiss your beliefs and demand the right to subjugate you.

• Societies are nothing more than endless struggles between oppressors and oppressed. It’s time for a new set of oppressors: Us.

• Merited success condemns merited failure therefore no success is merited.

• We’re leaving blue states because of the mess leftist politicians have made of them, and we’re moving to red states where we’ll vote for the same sort of leftist politicians who made us miserable in the blue states.

• The West is a racist, capitalistic hellscape. We must encourage mass immigration so that we can turn the West into the same sort of statist utopias from which the refugees are fleeing.

• We must focus on the West’s history of slavery and conquest that cannot be changed, while ignoring slavery and conquest currently practiced by non-western nations that can be changed.

• Government must be directed by the will of the people. Government must be directed by a technocracy that is shielded from politics.

• To ensure human flourishing, we must create incentives for people to demonstrate minimum ability and maximum need by distributing goods according to the dictum: “From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs.”

• Raising the cost of cigarettes will discourage people from smoking. Raising the cost of employing workers will not discourage businesses from hiring nor will rent controls cause housing shortages.

• Slavery – an economic system in which people can arbitrarily demand others’ time, labor, and produce – is bad. Social Justice – a philosophy that holds that “the oppressed” can arbitrarily demand others’ time, labor, and produce – is good.

• Monopoly by corporations – which must satisfy their customers to survive – is bad. Monopoly by government – which can use deadly force to survive – is good.

• We must take decisions out of the hands of individuals who understand local conditions, who can quickly respond to feedback, and who will pay a price if they choose poorly and place them in the hands of central planners who have limited knowledge and imperfect feedback mechanisms, and who pay no price for being wrong.

• We care so much about the plight of others that we will gladly give them the shirt off your back.

• The ATF, CFTC, CPSC, DEA, EEOC, EPA, FAA, FCA, FDA, FCC, FDIC, FERC, FHA, FRA, FTC, NLRB, NRC, OSHA, SEC, and Federal Reserve regulatory agencies must be strengthened because unfettered capitalism is failing.

• We are wisely teaching our children that two plus two equals whatever they want. Our bridges are collapsing, proving that capitalism is failing.

• We are banning nuclear, coal, hydroelectric, and natural gas power plants throughout the country. Free enterprise is failing to keep the lights on.

• Our ideas are contradictory only in the light of Western logic - a patriarchal and racist tool of oppression.

Expand full comment
128 more comments...

No posts